Museums as Advocates for Mental Health

It is well known that museums can have a significant positive impact on our quality of life. Art museums provide aesthetically pleasing environments for us to explore our identities. Science centers and natural history museums pique our curiosity, inspiring our quests for discovery. History museums offer portals to our shared past, allowing us to make sense of the present.

Not only do museums provide existential benefits, but they can also contribute to our wellbeing. In other words, a trip to the museum—like jogging or eating your vegetables—is a healthy choice.

The Arteffact Project undertook a study in 2012 to discover whether museums had a measurable positive effect on mental health. Their findings indicated that “creative activity in museums has a significant beneficial effect on the mental wellbeing of people suffering from mental distress and that the museum setting has contributed to this effect.” Participants described the museum environment as “inspirational and calming” and reported that “they experienced a connection to the human through interaction with the artifacts.”

It is vital that museums actively promote mental wellbeing and build upon studies like the one done by the Arteffact Project if they wish to fulfill their obligation to their communities.

Why Mental Health Matters

 Mental health is something we all struggle with at one point or another, but a significant number of people battle mental illness on a daily basis. For the sake of brevity, this post will only focus on the two most common mental illnesses: anxiety and depression. The Center for Disease Control (CDC) defines an anxiety disorder as “characterized by excessive and unrealistic worry about everyday tasks or events, or may be specific to certain objects or rituals.” The CDC defines depression as “characterized by persistent sadness and sometimes irritability and is one of the leading causes of disease or injury worldwide for both men and women.” While depression and anxiety are two separate illnesses, they share overlapping symptoms as demonstrated by the accompanying chart from Anxiety.org. It is also not uncommon for one person to have both anxiety and depression—a condition known as comorbidity.

d

According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), anxiety disorders affect 18% of the American population (approximately 40 million people) and depression affects 6.7% of the population (approximately 16 million people). Based on these statistics, it is safe to assume that someone with one or both of these afflictions is bound to walk through the doors of a museum at some point in time—if not everyday. Museums should therefore be prepared to meet his or her needs.

It is crucial that we talk about these conditions as a society because they are both potentially life threatening. Both anxiety and depression carry a high risk of suicide, which is the tenth leading cause of death in the United States. While suicide is an uncomfortable topic, “evidence shows that providing support services, talking about suicide, reducing access to means of self-harm, and following up with loved ones are just some of the actions we can all take to help others” (National Suicide Prevention Lifeline). With proper training and preparation, museums and other social institutions are appropriate spaces to have these tough conversations.

How Museums Can Help

According to museum educator Lois Silverman, “Through their therapeutic potential, museums have a means to social inclusion of individuals who are often overlooked by cultural institutions.” She argues that museums assume a healthy visitor population and ignore museums’ potential to “improve and/or maintain healthy human functioning and well-being.” At the beginning of this post, I presented evidence that museums have a positive effect on mental health. It is therefore time for museums to take advantage of this inherent therapeutic potential by actively promoting a healthy mental state and reaching out to people suffering from mental illness.

In some ways, museums naturally meet this audience’s needs already. For instance, Silverman identifies four concepts related to the therapeutic role of museums. They are:

  1. Artifacts – Museums use artifacts to share stories and invoke memories. Artifacts can thus be used as tools for self-exploration and growth.
  2. Interpretive media – Museums use a variety of means to reach their audiences and interpret their collections, including personal and non-personal services. Personal services in particular allow for direct communication, thus building empathy and understanding.
  3. Social roles – Museums provide a multiplicity of roles for their guests to inhabit. For instance, a visitor could assume the role of volunteer, contributor, enthusiast, connoisseur, etc. These roles can help visitors with mental illnesses realize that their illness does not define them.
  4. Evaluation – Museums rely on constant ongoing evaluation in order to maintain the quality of their programs and exhibits. Through evaluation, we can better understand how museums are already providing therapeutic benefits to their visitors.

There are also several ways that museums can better serve this population. Museums can…

  • Partner with mental health professionals and communities
  • Require staff trainings about mental health and suicide prevention
  • Create programs that encourage mindfulness and emotional wellbeing
  • Create therapy-based programs
  • Host lectures or lecture series about mental health
  • Create outreach programs for mental health facilities
  • Create safe and welcoming spaces

One of the most effective ways museums can address mental health is through programming. Examples of appropriate programming include:

Art therapy – Art therapy provides participants with a creative outlet to “explore their feelings, reconcile emotional conflicts, foster self-awareness, manage behavior and addictions, develop social skills, improve reality orientation, reduce anxiety, and increase self-esteem.” The Memphis Brooks Museum of Art’s Art Therapy Access Program partners with local organizations as well as a certified art therapist in order to “provide a supportive and creative environment for the participants to develop and explore their personal narratives through art-making and gallery discussions.”

Mindfulness Activities/Exercises – Mindfulness is defined as “a mental state achieved by focusing one’s awareness on the present moment, while calmly acknowledging and accepting one’s feelings, thoughts, and bodily sensations, used as a therapeutic technique.” The Rubin Museum of Art in New York hosts several series focused on mindfulness, such as Yoga Connections, Mindfulness Meditation, Breathe, and Awakening Practice. Awakening Practice, for example, explores Himalayan culture using guided meditation in the museum’s Shrine Room.

Reminiscence Therapy – Reminiscence therapy uses memory as a healing force, often calling upon objects to facilitate the act of remembrance. This form of therapy has proven to significantly reduce depression in people with dementia. The Lowewood Museum in England has a reminiscence therapy program called Memory Boxes, which is an outreach program that provides boxes containing memory-jogging objects to local care homes. The program helps “to reconnect a person with their identity and to improve communication, mood and overall wellbeing.”

Music Therapy – Music therapy uses music “to help people cultivate their physical, intellectual, emotional, and spiritual well-being.” The Explore Music Project Museum in Seattle has partnered with the Seattle Pacific University’s music therapy program in order to host music therapy camps for children with developmental disorders. The camps offer “opportunities for social engagement, enhanced awareness and appreciation of self and others, and creative expression through alternative communication styles of music-making.” While these camps were not intended for people with anxiety and depression, they meet both groups’ needs.

Conclusion

By accommodating the needs of visitors with anxiety and depression, museums not only become better institutions for those suffering from mental illness, they also become better institutions for everyone. Silverman writes, “Mental health is a common denominator, something all people need, and addressing it is a path to broader social inclusion by museums.” We can all benefit from a little self-care. When museums create opportunities for self-exploration and community building, they do more than just serve their visitors; they care for them.

If you or someone you know is contemplating suicide, consult the following resources immediately:

 

Resources and Further Reading:

9 thoughts on “Museums as Advocates for Mental Health

  1. julianavenegas

    Thank you for tackling this topic! I think museums can be awesome resources for mental health. One interesting idea, that I’m not sure if it would help or hurt, is to look at artifacts differently than proposed in your post. Not only can artifact helps with self-exploration and growth, but perhaps they can teach us about the past in terms of how mental health was treated or discussed in the past and how far (or not) we’ve come. I remember one time in Turkey, we visited the ruins of an ancient hospital. There, we walked through a tunnel/covered walkway that had tiny windows in the ceiling. It is said that these holes were where doctors stood and whispered positive sentiments to the patients walking through, so that when the patients came out, they felt more positive, some even ‘healed’. This really helped me begin to think how we handle mental health today. So perhaps this wouldn’t be a productive or helpful way to use artifacts for those directly effected by various mental health diseases and conditions, but it could help educate others on how to interact or help those they may or may not know with various diagnoses.

    Overall, though, I love your suggestions and the way you approached this topic within museums.

    Like

    Reply
  2. Cristina

    Taylor,
    Let me first begin by thanking you for sharing this topic with the class. I am very familiar with how art can heal and help us over come obstacles. I couldn’t agree more that museums should take an active role in promoting mental wellbeing. As future museum professionals we have a duty to help our community and should do so by understanding museums benefits in all capacities.

    Like

    Reply
    1. caitlinefblake

      Echoing Cristina. But also, while I had considered art as something that can heal and help, I never considered the possibility of museum spaces being a place to heal and help. Thank you @Taylor for opening my eyes! Museums have great potential to facilitate healing within their spaces– I would love to see NGA, SAAM, or the Hirshhorn hold programs focused on mental health and healing.

      Like

      Reply
  3. katebreichert

    Thank you for this thoughtful post! As somebody who both manages panic disorder personally and supports family members who suffer extreme anxiety disorders, it’s exciting to think of museums as places of peace and revitalization. The examples of therapy programming already being integrated into museums around the world are wonderful, and make me think about what else can be done to ensure that those who would benefit most from these programs feel comfortable enough to participate, mainly in services offered by the museum. For example, crowds and money concerns can be triggers of anxiety, and personal belongings (water, food, medication, layers of clothing, etc) might be critical to ensuring comfort. Ensuring visitors who may be coming to the museum with anxiety disorders that they will have the space to explore with smaller crowds (perhaps indicating slow days, limiting program numbers, or monitoring flow in certain exhibit spaces), space to store important belongings or freedom to carry personal items (bags, etc) with them, and trained staff (as you mention) that are able to respond to any visitor needs with respect and discretion would all be invaluable to those managing their mental health.

    Like

    Reply
  4. kellyrweiss

    Taylor thank you for tackling such a personal and sensitive topic so tactfully. Museums have always been a refuge for me and a tool that I have used to promote my own mental health over the years. Much like Kate mentioned above, I have my own struggles with mental health, and museums have always been a place where I can go and (for the most part) not have to worry about them temporarily, and all of this happens just by being in a museum! If I can find such peace just by being in a museum with little to no effort on their part, the possibilities are endless for when institutions start stepping up and directly designing programming for mental health benefits. As you mentioned, staff training is key to the success of such programs and CONTINUED staff training is vital due to turn-over and with the emergence of new research and best practices. I really appreciate that you touched on reminiscence therapy as well, because this is something that I wish I had known existed for certain members of my own family.

    Like

    Reply
  5. Kristina Seals

    I think promoting museums as a space to find relief from mental health issues is a wonderful idea. I myself need to remember the many wonderful spaces which are free in D.C. to take advantage of when school becomes stressful. Promoting museum spaces for support groups to gather is a good idea as well. I have seen depression groups who meet up to walk or just get out in the community. Using the museum space as a place to gather and perhaps use artwork to help discuss how one is feeling.

    Like

    Reply
  6. mep17ruthann

    I think there is a huge potential for museums to be advocates and platforms for spreading awareness of mental illnesses while also providing programing that can help support a community around mental illness’s needs. Through providing greater access to information about mental illness the museum can act as a platform that helps to break down the stigmas around mental illness. This is much needed for helping people who are struggling, to feel safe in seeking help and treatment without judgment from their communities. Programing shouldn’t just focus on those with a mental illness but those that are in their lives as well. This could help family and friends know how to react to various situations and provide appropriate care.

    Like

    Reply
  7. erinmkohler

    Taylor,
    Your blog post is full of great information, but I especially love how you say, “Not only do museums provide existential benefits, but they can also contribute to our wellbeing. In other words, a trip to the museum—like jogging or eating your vegetables—is a healthy choice.” It’s so true! It is something everyone needs to remember. I also appreciate that you point to the fact that by helping museums become better places for people with anxiety and depression, they become better places for all. This is so true! It’s a philosophy that I have applied to my lesson plans, adding aides for those with special needs helps everyone!

    Like

    Reply
  8. museumpeople

    Thanks for addressing anxiety and depression–so many people in our society suffer from anxiety or depression or both at some point during their lives. The idea that museums and other cultural institutions could acknowledge this and help address it is very exciting. Especially because there has been a stigma attached to these disordered historically. That is changing now, but we still have a way to go. I personally suffer from lifelong clinical depression, and have found help through art and music. I love the idea that museums could even market themselves as places for stress relief and healing.

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s